Posts Tagged ‘customer experience’

A Review of American Airlines’ Mobile Boarding Pass

Friday, November 28th, 2008

Any company with a mobile interest is creating new customer experiences faster than you can say “iPhone.” An interesting one is American Airlines’ mobile boarding pass.  In this experience, innovative mobile bar codes allow customers to check in board using their only phones—no paper needed.

An example of a mobile barcode

An example of a mobile barcode

Kudos to American Airlines for trying to take the mobile experience to the next level. This approach sounds excellent in theory and, indeed, mobile bar codes have tremendous potential across many industries, including travel. But using a new technology does not replace the need to plan and design the user / customer experience appropriately.  As this UX review from Data Collection Online suggests, the American Airlines experience has many kinks to work out.  Perhaps the most important kinks are

  • Not clearly setting customers’ expectations.
    If the customer does not have the right type of phone, you need to tell the customer up front.
  • Having too many steps, clicks, and downloads in the process.
    When paper starts to seem much more desirable than the mobile process, something is wrong.  The experience needs to be quick and seamless.

Working out these kinks is very possible.  I wish American Airlines good luck in refining their innovative mobile experience into a winning one.

The American Airlines mobile boarding pass on the iPhone

The American Airlines mobile boarding pass

When UX Misunderstands Marketing…

Wednesday, October 1st, 2008

I just read a rather bothersome post, The marketing view of user-centered design, on the highly respected blog Putting people first.  The post takes excerpts from an article about customer-centric marketing and says they are marketing’s perspective on UCD.  I don’t understand the logic.  The article does not mention UCD or claim to cover how to develop products and services.  What the article does do, however, is emphasize understanding and listening to customers for brand differentiation, message development, and feedback on products and services.  All good things.  Marketing can get very focused on the message a company is trying to convey and lose sight of who they are conveying to.  To conclude from the article that marketing views UCD a certain way is illogical and unfair because the article was not trying to express a view on it.  We can’t assume that just because the author did not mention UCD that he has a certain view of it.

More disturbing about the Putting people first post, however, is the view of marketing as easy, or a “piece of cake” with good products and services.  This could imply that UX or UCD is superior to marketing.  While this post was not smug, I hear many smug comments from UX professionals about marketing. I am afraid they will interpret the post as more justification to keep doing so.  If a smug attitude toward marketing is growing in the UX community, it needs to stop.  Why?  Because the UX and marketing communities need to collaborate well to create the best possible customer experience.

I think this smugness comes partly from misunderstanding marketing.  It is easy to condemn what one doesn’t understand.  In my UXMatters article “Marketing Isn’t a Dirty Word,” I provide some insight.  I only scratch the surface, but I think it helps show why well-implemented marketing is complex and valuable.

This smugness also may stem from experiences with bad marketing implementations or less-than-stellar representatives of marketing.  Understanding marketing can help with those issues, too.

I completely agree with Putting people first that marketing should flow from good products and services with a strong user experience influence.  I simply disagree that it makes marketing easy and the implication that it makes user experience superior.

Service Experience Depends on Content

Monday, September 29th, 2008

I recently helped design a music mastering service from soup to nuts.  So fun!  The process reminded me that content plays a key role in the service experience.  I first became aware of this fact a few years ago at Cingular Wireless, where the human-centered design team worked on projects for all customer touchpoints—IVR, store kiosk, customer service representative, website, you name it.  Get the content wrong in or across any of those touchpoints, and the service experience implodes.  Here are a few specific reasons why well-crafted content adds business value to a service.

Content Greases the Wheels of a Long-Term Service Relationship

The business-customer relationship for a product often is short term.  The customer shops, compares, buys, and then the relationship is mostly over. With a service, the relationship often is long term. When a customer signs up for a service, whether a mobile service plan or NetFlix, she often is signing up for a period of time or certain number of uses.  If anything requires good communication, it’s a long-term relationship. ;-) The substance of this communication is largely content.

  • The business has to communicate to the customer: account status, order history and status, bill statements, special offer notifications, announcements of new benefits or features, technical support and more.
    • This content needs to be accurate, credible, reliable, easily accessible, and easily understandable.
    • If the content is not, customers will lose confidence or become confused and even angered.
  • In turn, the customer may need to communicate to the business: change in preferences, bill questions, technical questions, and more.
    • The service needs to provide a way for customers to communicate with it, plus content that helps explain or support interactions and to answer questions.
    • Again, this content needs to be credible, reliable, easily accessible, and easily understandable.

Content Adds a Personal, Differentiating Tone to the Automated Aspects of a Service

Of course, the direction of many services is automation, such as paying the service bill online.  Automation saves businesses money by being more efficient and requiring fewer employees.  Automation often is more convenient for customers, as well. The tricky part? Preserving a personal feel or tone in the service, especially for the long term.  How can you make your service seem different from your competitor’s if it is largely automated?  One way is through outstanding content that has a distinctive voice.

For the music mastering service I mentioned earlier, the president had a large hand in crafting the content’s voice.  I think it largely worked because he designed the service for someone like him. The voice seemed authentic. Also, many of the “web 2.0″ services have extremely informal and human-sounding content, which I think helps create an authentic voice.  A huge brand for many products and services that has impressively managed to keep a distinct voice is Virgin.  I look forward to seeing how voice evolves as service design grows.

Virgin's distinct voice appears even on a log in page

Virgin's unmistakable brash voice is clear even on a log in page.

More on Service Experience and Design

Authenticity: There, Gone, and Back Again

Monday, September 15th, 2008

Last week I enjoyed a vacation in Vermont.  If there was one word that came to mind over and over again, it was “authentic.”  No obnoxious billboards.  Lots of gorgeous farms.  Scarce fast food and retail chains.  Lots of quaint, if not quirky, inns and restaurants.  I felt almost transported to another country or a previous time, where things seem a little more genuine somehow.

A covered bridge in Vermont

A covered bridge on a Vermont road.

Today I returned not just to the visual cacophony of billboards and the sameness of chains but also to the U.S. stock market fall.  The Dow Jones lost 500 points.  Why such a tumble?  Though the answer has many facets, I think its core is lack of authenticity.  People invested in something that wasn’t really there….in the real estate sector where predatory loans gave people houses they couldn’t afford and earned profits that didn’t last.  And not just any people invested in this mirage of money.  Major financials did, bringing themselves down and bringing Wall Street down with them.  By this afternoon, I was quite distressed.

This evening I read a post on the analytics blog Occam’s Razor by Avinash Kaushik.  It was an update on a “little book” he wrote called Web Analytics: An Hour a Day.  Like many of his posts, this one delivered its message in occasionally unidiomatic English peppered with enthusiastic asides, emoticons, and exclamation points.  Among the images was a flower and the cover from the Little Engine That Could.  Quirky, indeed.  This genuine style contrasts nicely with the intimidating subject of web analytics.  Today, for me, it contrasted with the spurious investments on Wall Street.  An even greater counterpoint was the post’s message.  It seems Kaushik is donating 100% of his book royalties to two charities, Doctors without Borders and The Smile Train.  So far he has donated $28,000.  Yes, he still enjoys indirect benefits of being a successful author and analytics expert.  But giving up the cash is literally putting your money where your mouth is.  Nothing fake about it.  Tonight, I feel a little more hopeful.

I can’t help but think authenticity is key to lasting influence and, ultimately, a winning experience for all.  In the case of Wall Street, what seemed to be a win-win-lose situation for predatory lendors, investors, and homeowners has devolved into a lose-lose-lose situation.  Web Analytics is a win-win-win situation for Kaushik, the readers, and the charities.  May it inspire more.

Content Is More Than Copy

Saturday, September 6th, 2008

When I talk to people — clients, UX professionals, interactive marketers — about content, I find an assumption often lurks beneath their comments.  What’s that assumption?  It’s content = copy.  From that assumption follows many other unspoken assumptions that give me the willies:

  • We can scrounge the content together at the last minute. 
  • Anyone who can write a sentence can develop content.
  • We shouldn’t invest money in content.  We should invest it in technical development.
  • We don’t have to do much to keep content fresh or of high quality.
  • We need to worry about content for just one project, product, or channel at a time.

No, no, a thousand times no! Content is so much more than copy.  Content is strategic. This perspective is critical to making the right design and investment decisions for a product or an interactive marketing effort.  Here’s my stab at explaining why.

The Literal Explanation: Content Is Other Things, Too

Sure, copy / text is a big part of content…so are these things:

  • Photos and images
  • Data and numbers and related visualizations of them
  • Videos

What is more, usually these items have a relationship with the text, such as supporting or further explaining the text.  If you think content is only copy, you’re probably neglecting these other types of content.  And you’re likely not coordinating them well with the copy.


Photos are  quite literally content.  For more, see my friend Nick’s blog.

The Philosophical Explanation: Content Automates and Differentiates

Businesses are using interactive channels more and more for self-service, where customers can help themselves.  Some folks such as Daniel Pink say we’re entering an age of more automation than ever.  Also, Forrester reports continue to show that the trend toward self-service is only rising. That means interactive channels are not just conveying a message.  They are replacing human interactions.  They are providing the service.  We can shop online, manage accounts online, pay bills over the phone, receive shipping notifications by text message, check in to flights with a kiosk.  So our content needs to provide the “human” factor.  It needs to speak like an ingenious sales person, a helpful customer service representative, an affable technical support expert, and more.  The content needs to do everything possible to help customers succeed in using self-service.

I’d say that’s a big job you can’t throw together at the last minute. :-)

Furthermore, usability and technical performance will be important to self-service — but not the differentiator.  Thanks to the keen awareness of usability in the interactive and user experience world, everyone will be concerned about usability and technical performance.  Your company, your competitors, everyone. It’s obvious a customer can’t get service from a hard-to-use, slow, or buggy application.  But usability and technical performance only get you on the playing field.  What gives you the winning edge is persuasive, useful content.

Sound far-fetched?  Consider this. At the close of 2006, Forrester released a report entitled “Use Persuasive Content to Improve the Customer Experience.” This report calls for less emphasis on the technical aspects of content management systems and more emphasis on the content itself.  To quote:

Information and knowledge management professionals who support eBusiness, multichannel, and Web content management initiatives can drive signficant improvements in customer experiences. How? By putting more emphasis on using content to help customers — whether  it is providing relevant information when customers buy a product or delivering easy-to-use or understandable content for customer self-service Websites — rather than simply focusing on how to create, manage, and search for content.

Let’s stop treating content like it’s crap work.  Let’s get serious about content, for it’s key to helping customers and differentiating our companies, our products, ourselves.  Content is more than copy!

The Persuasive Power of Storytelling

Thursday, July 10th, 2008

For my first post, I want to share one of my favorite ways to take website content from blah to brilliant - telling a story.

A story appeals to our emotional and rational sides at the same time and, therefore, boosts persuasive impact. Stories give context and impart feeling to facts. Stories also follow our natural memory patterns, so they’re easy to remember. It’s the difference between memorizing facts about the invasion of Normandy and experiencing it in the movie Saving Private Ryan.

One important type of story is the customer testimonial, which shows specifically how a brand’s product or service makes customers’ lives better. For example, a recent series of iPhone commercials showcases real users explaining a situation in which the iPhone saved the day. In one instance, shown in Figure 7, a customer talks about how visual voicemail lets him easily pick which voicemails to listen to and which voicemails—such as one from a customer who owes him money—to delete.

A customer tells a story about the iphone

For more about the power of storytelling, see my article “Become an Interactive Storyteller.”